MALAYSIA SHOULD EXPEDITE THE ABOLITION OF THE DEATH PENALTY
MADPET(Malaysians Against Death
Penalty and Torture), on the occasion of the 12th World Day Against the Death
Penalty (10/10/2014) reiterates the call for Malaysia to abolish the Death
Penalty, and immediately impose a moratorium on executions pending abolition as
per the United Nation General Assembly’s Resolutions that have been adopted in 2007,
2008, 2010, 2012, whereby every year the support of the global community has
been increasing.
The possibility of miscarriage or
failure of justice in the implementation of the death penalty is irreversible
and irreparable is one reason why the Death Penalty needs to be abolished. We recall
the words of the then Malaysian Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department
Datuk Seri Nazri Abdul Aziz. “No criminal justice system is perfect. You take a
man’s life and years later, you find out that another person did the crime.
What can you do?”(Star, 29/8/2010, Abolish death penalty, it’s incorrect to
take someone’s life, says Nazri), which becomes even more
significant today in the light of the recent cases which resulted in the death
of an innocent man, and spending up to 45 years on death row
* "My
son was killed for a crime he did not
commit…. our family has lived in shame and neighbours never spoke to
us. Whatever apology or compensation the government promises, it is too late.”-
Wang Tsai-lien, mother of Chiang Kuo-ching who was coerced into making a
confession and subsequently executed in error in 1997 in Taiwan. In January 2011, Taiwan’s Ministry of
Justice admitted that Chiang Kuo-ching, a private in the Air Force, had been
executed in error in 1997 for a murder committed 15 years previously.
* On 27 March 2014, 78 year old Iwao Hakamada, who had spent more than 45 years on death row was
freed. A retrial was ordered. The
presiding judge, Hiroaki Murayama, when releasing Hakamada also had this to
say, "There is a possibility that [key pieces of] evidence have been
fabricated by investigative bodies,"
* In March 2014, Glenn Ford in USA was freed from death row after 30 years. Evidence had
surfaced that he was innocent. Ford becomes the 144th death row inmate to be
exonerated over the past four decades, underlining the perils of innocent
people being sent to their deaths in America’s capital punishment system.
The
problems of miscarriage of justice is that many a time it is linked to the
police and prosecutors, and just this month, in Vietnam for having upheld the
sentence of a man sentenced to life in a prison for a murder he did not commit,
a former Judge has been arrested and is being investigated for gross
negligence, whilst the police and prosecutors are being investigated on charges of “deliberate falsification of trial
documents.” Lawyers too can cause miscarriage of justice, more so when many a
person facing the death penalty cannot afford their own lawyers and will have
to rely on court appointed lawyers.
Now, in Malaysia noting
the number of death in police custody cases, we have to be even more concerned. Persons tortured will admit to
committing an offence even when innocent.
Police, prosecutors, defence
lawyers, judges and even witnesses can
make mistakes, and innocent persons can end up being hanged. There are likely to
be many cases of innocent persons languishing on death row, waiting to be
hanged, but alas because of lack of resources or support, this fact of their
innocence will never likely be brought out.
Another reason that has
been advance by Malaysia for the retention of the death penalty has been
deterrence – the fact that people will be put to death will scare possible
perpetrators and reduce crime but alas this assertion has never been proven
scientifically. Many research have shown that the contrary it true.
In March 2012, it was also revealed
in Parliament by Home Minister Hishammuddin Hussein that the mandatory death
penalty has been shown to have failed to act as a deterrent. Police statistics
for the arrests of drug dealers under Section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act
1952, which carries the mandatory death penalty, for the past three years (2009
to 2011) have shown an increase. In 2009, there were 2,955 arrested under this
section. In 2010, 3,700 people were arrested, whilst in 2011, there were 3,845
arrested.(Free Malaysia Today
News, 19/3/2012, Death penalty not deterring drug trade). Malaysian
Crime Prevention Foundation vice chairman Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye also did note in
July 2013 that the death sentence had not deterred the drug trade.
In Malaysia, the majority of the
persons that are in death row are for Drug Offences, but alas, unlike the norm
in most criminal cases where the burden of proving all elements that constitute
the crime is on the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, in the case
of drug trafficking which carries the death penalty, the burden shifts to the
accused person to prove that he is not a drug trafficker. Possession of a
certain quantity of drugs invokes the legal presumption that the person in
possession is a drug trafficker; and reasonably it will be a near impossible task
for any accused to prove that drugs were not his, or that he is not a drug trafficker.
Most accused persons do not have the resources for investigation, or even the
ability to identify and/or call witnesses. The existence of such a legal
presumption and the shifting of the burden to the accused to prove his
innocence would, in our opinion, make such trials an unfair trial.
It is very serious when we consider that since 1960 until 2011,
228 persons(or 52% of those hanged) executed in Malaysia was for the offence of
drug trafficking, and there was then 479(or 69%) persons on death row for the
same offence. (Home Minister’s
Reply, Free Malaysia Today, 3/4/2011) There was a total 930 death row prisoners
were in jails in the country as of Aug 31 2012.(New Straits Times, 10/10/2012, 930 on death row as of Aug 31, says
Abu Seman), Today, there will be even more on death row
It was disturbing when Malaysia tried to hang Chandran s/o Paskaran, convicted for murder on 7/2/2014, and later Osariakhi Ernest Obayangbon (aka Philip Michael), convicted for murder, on 14/3/2014 but thankfully through the intervention of the Royalty, Attorney General and the government that was initially moved by civil society, their lives was saved. This attempts to execute was most disturbing since Malaysia seem to have not hanged any person for several years, and was also currently seriously reviewing and considering the abolition of the Death Penalty. It should also be stated that Malaysia needs to be more open and transparent with statistics and information especially if there will be any pending executions.
The global trend is towards abolition, and Malaysia
shamefully sits together with about 58 retentionist countries. There are 140
countries that have abolished the death penalty in law or in practice, and this
includes 5 out of the 10 ASEAN nations, being Brunei, Phillipines, Cambodia,
Myanmmar and Laos.
MADPET has been
calling for the abolition of the death penalty since 2005. On 7/5/2006, a call-
in-poll conducted by a local radio station revealed that 64% of Malaysian were
for abolition. In 3/11/2012, 79 groups including 29 Malaysian groups called for
the abolition of the Death Penalty. At the last Universal Periodic Review of
Malaysia in October 2013, United
Nations member countries urged Malaysia to abolish capital punishment and
repeal oppressive laws. The European Union have been calling for abolition, the
last being on 9/10/2014. On 22/7/2014, once again the Malaysian Human Rights
Commission called for the abolition of the death penalty, urging at the very
least the removal of the mandatory death sentence and returning to the courts
(judges) the discretionary powers in imposing much more appropriate sentences,
including life sentences. The Malaysian Bar has been constantly calling for the
abolition of the death penalty.
MADPET
reiterates its call for the abolition of the death penalty in Malaysia, for an
immediate moratorium on all executions pending abolition and for the
commutation of the sentences of all persons currently on death row;
We also call on
Malaysia to ratify the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).
Charles Hector
For and on behalf of MADPET(Malaysians Against Death Penalty
and Torture)
10 October 2014
No comments:
Post a Comment